• Skip to main content

Global Institute of Organizational Coaching

Global Coaching Certification

  • Explore Pathways
  • Dr Peggy’s Books
  • Resources
  • Log In
  • About

Sustaining Impact

Beyond the Spark: Why We Don’t Sustain Change

July 2, 2025 by Dr. Peggy Marshall

Excited group of people with colored square background

Let me say something that might be unpopular.

I’m tired of the motivational speakers and social media influencers who sell inspiration like it’s the whole story. You know the ones they show up on big stages with lights, music, and perfectly curated soundbites. They charge thousands for access. They get the crowd to cry, cheer, and dream big and then they walk away.

No follow-up. No integration. No relationship. Just a dopamine hit and a merch table.

Don’t get me wrong people want hope. And I’ve been moved, even transformed, by powerful moments or messages. But here's what I’ve learned again and again in my work with leaders, teams, and change-makers:

Inspiration is the spark. It is not the fire.

The fire is built afterward. In the friction. In the repetition. In the quiet discomfort of trying to live what you felt was true once the room is empty and the buzz has worn off.

So why don’t we sustain change—when we know so much about how?

Over the past two decades, more than 30,000 books have been published on personal development and performance psychology. They offer steps, strategies, habits, and hacks. We’ve never had more access to information on how to change our health, our mindset, our leadership, our lives. And yet, real transformation still feels elusive.

So many of us start strong and fall back. We set bold intentions. We attend the retreat. We finish the course. We write in journals, plan, visualize, and promise ourselves. And still two weeks later, we slip. The momentum fades. The old pattern reappears. And worst of all, we internalize it as failure.

We think: Maybe I’m not disciplined enough. Maybe I didn’t want it badly enough. Maybe I’m just not cut out for this. But here’s the truth: you are not the problem.

The real problem isn’t change itself, it’s how we’ve been taught to relate to it. Most systems whether in books, workshops, or coaching models, focus on behavior. They ask, What do you want to do differently? but rarely ask the deeper questions: How do you feel about the version of you that came before? What is your relationship to the new person emerging?

But change isn’t just about doing it, it’s about transforming. And transformation doesn’t happen through information alone. It unfolds through connection, through meaning, through daily practice. Identity doesn’t shift because we read a book or set a goal, it shifts when we learn to hold ourselves with compassion, honor the past, and step into a more aligned future. Until we change how we relate to change, we’ll keep mistaking performance for transformation and wondering why it doesn’t last.

The Myth of Motivation

One of the biggest lies we’ve absorbed is that motivation is enough. That if we just stay inspired, we’ll stay on track. But motivation is emotional, it rises and falls. It’s affected by sleep, stress, hormones, setbacks, and life. It can’t hold the weight of sustainable change on its own. And when we rely on it as our only fuel, we collapse the moment it dips. This is why so many people crash after the high. A leader leaves a conference fired up, only to feel lost two weeks later. A team returns from a retreat energized, only to fall back into old dynamics. A coaching client gains clarity, only to spiral when real life doesn’t reflect the shift they envisioned.

And again, they blame themselves. Not the system. Not the missing support. Not the fact that no one taught them how to stay in the work after the spark.

What’s Missing Isn’t Passion. It’s Practice.

What’s missing from so many personal growth experiences isn’t desire it’s design.

We aren’t taught how to stay with the discomfort that follows awareness. We aren’t given the tools to hold tension between who we’ve been and who we’re becoming. We aren’t guided through the middle the part that isn’t glamorous, but absolutely essential.

Real change requires a shift in relationship. Not just with the new behavior, but with the old one, too. In other words, we don’t just need to adopt new habits we need to honor, examine, and gently release the ones that once made us feel safe or successful. That’s the part no one talks about. Because it’s not sexy. It doesn’t sell as easily. It requires a slower, more soulful conversation.

From Spark to Sustaining Impact

That’s why I wrote Sustaining Impact which will hit the stores next month!  Not to offer a hype machine or a ten-step blueprint. But to create something different. Something slower, deeper, and more honest. A rhythm. A practice. A framework that honors the human complexity of change and stays with you through the middle.

Sustaining Impact is for the ones who have tried and stumbled. For the leaders who’ve left conferences on fire, only to feel the burnout a month later. For the high achievers who’ve read all the books and still feel like something’s missing.

It’s not about doing more. It’s about becoming more aligned with who you are, what you value, and what you’re ready to embody. Sustained impact is not built on intensity. It’s built on integration. That means reconnecting to your purpose when things get hard. Returning to your values when the noise gets loud. Practicing presence when perfection tries to take over.

What We Really Need

We don’t need more motivational slogans. We need more guides through the middle. We need conversations that don’t just ask what we want to change, but why it matters, how it feels, and who we’re becoming along the way. We need leaders and coaches who are willing to do the unsexy work of integration who know that real success isn’t just in the launch, but in the sustain.

We need to stop measuring change by how fast we get results and start asking how deeply we’re living the values we claim to hold. It’s a daily return. A quiet choice. A deeper rhythm. If you’ve ever felt like you were the only one struggling to hold onto the spark after the high wore off, I want you to know: you’re not alone. You’re just in the middle. And you’re right where the real work begins.

Ready to Move from Insight to Integration?

You don’t have to navigate the middle alone.

Take the free 45-item Sustaining Impact Self-Assessment to uncover your three lowest-scoring pathways, the areas most likely to hold you back from lasting change. Whether you’re struggling with clarity, commitment, momentum, or renewal, this personalized tool will help you identify where to reinvest and how to build forward.

You will receive a report with resources for working with your three lowest pathways.

Take the free assessment here!

Schedule a private coaching session with the author, Dr. Marshall, to unpack your results and create a roadmap

Sign up for the 3-month Sustaining Impact coaching package, designed to help you embody change with rhythm, support, and accountability

Click here for more information on those two programs.
Sustaining Impact Executive Coaching - Global Institute of Organizational Coaching

Don’t just spark change. Let’s sustain it.

Filed Under: Sustaining Impact

In Good Company: The Role of Others in Sustaining Change

July 17, 2025 by Dr. Peggy Marshall

Change often begins in solitude with a whisper, a longing, a decision made in the privacy of our own inner world. We feel the pull to live more honestly, to lead more courageously, to let go of old patterns or step into something new. That moment of choosing can feel deeply personal, even vital. But while the decision to change may begin alone, the capacity to sustain that change rarely grows in isolation.

We live in a culture that glorifies individual effort. We celebrate self-made stories and reward perseverance. But the truth is, transformation is relational. It unfolds more fully, more sustainably, when we are witnessed, supported, and held.

When we try to grow alone, we often internalize every setback as a flaw in character. We assume our fatigue means we’ve failed. We question whether we’re strong enough, committed enough, or deserving enough to keep going. But in the presence of others who are also on the path others who understand the messiness of change, the narrative begins to shift. What felt like personal deficiency begins to be seen as a natural part of the journey.

Parker Palmer writes, “The human soul doesn’t want to be advised or fixed or saved. It simply wants to be witnessed.” In times of change, what we often need most is not more advice, but presence. People who can sit with us in the in-between, when the old way no longer fits but the new path is still being formed. People who can remind us who we are when we forget and gently hold us accountable to who we’re becoming.

This kind of community allows us to show up without the need to perform. It makes room for authenticity and honors the natural pace of becoming. Rather than pushing for progress or certainty, it offers a kind of spaciousness a place where we can soften into our own unfolding. In Palmer’s language, it becomes a “circle of trust,” not necessarily formal or structured, but grounded in mutual respect. In that space, the masks can fall away, and truth can surface without fear.

Brené Brown reminds us that “Connection is why we're here. We are hardwired to connect with others.” In her research on shame and vulnerability, she speaks of how isolation magnifies our inner doubts. Without connection, our fears echo louder. Our stories go unchecked, and we can lose perspective. But when we risk being seen when we let ourselves be known in both our courage and our uncertainty, we find something vital. Not just support, but resonance. The recognition that we are not alone and never were.

Community, in this way, becomes more than a support system. It becomes a mirror. A space where our deeper truth is reflected back to us, not distorted by performance or pretense. It reminds us that growth is not about perfection. It’s about presence. And presence is made more possible when we’re not carrying it all alone.

In the Sustaining Impact framework, we often speak of rhythm, identity, and integration as core components of lasting change. But what sustains those components, what gives them texture and breath is community. A friend who calls you back to your purpose when your energy wavers. A mentor who helps you distinguish fear from intuition. A team who names your progress when you’re too tired to see it yourself. These connections don’t replace the inner work; they amplify it and make it livable.

Community matters not only in times of struggle, but in moments of celebration. It is easy to overlook our own progress, especially when it arrives in subtle or incomplete forms. We move quickly from one effort to the next, often brushing past what we’ve done. Yet something meaningful happens when another person sees what we might have missed. When a trusted voice affirms, “That mattered,” the moment becomes fuller, more real. Emotionally and physiologically, we begin to register the impact. Our bodies settle and our minds lean in. The path forward feels just a little more possible. Encouragement, when grounded in relationship, reminds us that we are not alone and that the work we’re doing is worth continuing.

We must remember that not every space invites growth. While community can be a profound source of strength, not all connections nourish who we are becoming. Some reinforce outdated roles, expectations, or identities we’ve outgrown. They ask us to dim, to edit, to perform. Part of sustaining impact is learning to notice the difference to recognize the places where we feel seen and supported, and those where we find ourselves shrinking in order to belong. True community does not require self-abandonment. It makes room for our full presence. It invites us to bring our complexity, our truth, and our evolving sense of self without apology.

This doesn’t mean surrounding yourself only with like-minded people. In fact, some of the richest growth happens in diverse, even challenging, communities where your worldview is expanded, where assumptions are lovingly questioned, where you learn to stay in dialogue even when it’s uncomfortable. What matters is not uniformity, but mutual respect. A shared commitment to holding space for truth, curiosity, and transformation.

You don’t need a large network to feel supported. Often, it is a small circle of intentional relationships that carries the greatest weight. A trusted peer who listens without judgment. A thoughtful coach who reflects your values back to you. A community of practice where growth is shared, not performed. Or a single conversation partner who helps you see more clearly and feel more deeply. These relationships do not solve the journey for you, but they walk beside you in a way that makes the journey more honest, more grounded, and more whole.

And when change becomes hard and it will, community becomes the ground that holds us. Not to carry our work, but to remind us we’re not carrying it alone. That we are seen, even in the struggle. That we can reconnect to the commitments we’ve made, because someone else is holding that vision with us.

As you reflect on your own journey whether you’re at the beginning of a change, in the middle of a plateau, or somewhere in between ask yourself not only what you want to change, but who is walking with you. Who helps you stay honest? Who celebrates your becoming? Who gently calls you back to what you said matters most?

And just as meaningful, consider whose journey you are accompanying. Whose growth you are quietly witnessing. In offering presence to others, we deepen our own. Community is not simply supporting change, it is part of the transformation itself. Through relationship, we remember our shared humanity. We grow into alignment. And we begin to embody the kind of change that lasts.

Call to Action!

Now I have a call to action for this community, a faculty member, Carol Assalian, is completing her masters thesis at the University of Wales, Trinity St. David.  She needs participants in her study which is examining the role of leaders/supervisors in Self-Efficacy.  It’s a brief assessment, should not take longer than five-eight minutes and can be accessed here.  Your participation will be greatly appreciated!

Questionnaire LINK :

https://forms.cloud.microsoft/e/bp3nb7Vznt

 

 

Filed Under: Sustaining Impact

  • | Home |
  • Leader Development Pathways
  • | Executive Coaching |
  • Team Coaching
  • | Sustaining Impact |
  • Detach from Drama
  • | Coach Cultures at Global IOC |
  • My Account |

Copyright Global IOC© 2026